ARC Reviews, Book Reviews, Mystery, Thriller/Suspense/Crime Fiction

Book Review: Before the Fall by Noah Hawley


When a fellow member in my book club suggested we read Before the Fall for our book of the month, I jumped at the opportunity & quickly seconded the notion.  Why yes, I did need to read it anyways because it was on my NetGalley eARC TBR list, therefore I already had a copy… Ok, I was killing two birds with one stone, but can you blame me?


BeforetheFallAuthor: Noah Hawley

Genre: Mystery • Thriller

Version: eBook

Publisher: Grand Central Publishing

Source: NetGalley


Book Description

On a foggy summer night, eleven people–ten privileged, one down-on-his-luck painter–depart Martha’s Vineyard headed for New York. Sixteen minutes later, the unthinkable happens: the passengers disappear into the ocean. The only survivors are Scott Burroughs–the painter–and a four-year-old boy, who is now the last remaining member of a wealthy and powerful media mogul’s family.
With chapters weaving between the aftermath of the tragedy and the backstories of the passengers and crew members–including a Wall Street titan and his wife, a Texan-born party boy just in from London, a young woman questioning her path in life, and a career pilot–the mystery surrounding the crash heightens. As the passengers’ intrigues unravel, odd coincidences point to a conspiracy: Was it merely dumb chance that so many influential people perished? Or was something far more sinister at work? Events soon threaten to spiral out of control in an escalating storm of media outrage and accusations–all while the reader draws closer and closer to uncovering the truth.
The fragile relationship between Scott and the young boy glows at the heart of this novel, raising questions of fate, human nature, and the inextricable ties that bind us together.


    Before the Fall was definitely not what I was expecting, but that isn’t necessarily a bad thing.  Where I was anticipating an action packed thriller, I actually got a character driven story about survival, fate, & self-discovery.  Sure, this book is about the aftermath of a plane crash, but it is also about the characters BEFORE the crash (hence the title), and how these characters all came to be on the plane in the first place.

Everyone is from someplace. We all have stories, our lives unfolding along crooked lines, colliding in unexpected ways.

I really enjoy how Hawley constructed this story: giving us the event first (plane crash), then weaving back and forth between the present day investigation into the crash and the lives & backstories of the characters leading up to the crash.  We know the “what” but now we need to know the “who” and the “why.”  I wouldn’t classify Before the Fall as a “thriller” in the traditional sense, but that the majority of the book felt more like a mystery.  Despite it not being an action packed read, I still would consider it a page turner.  Through the characters’ backstories, we slowly are given pieces to the puzzle, thus enabling the reader begins to form their own theories into the “who” & the “why.”  Was this an accident?  A plot to take down one of the powerful men on board?  Or was there something more sinister at play here?  I just HAD to know what really happened.

Before the Fall made for a good book club selection because there were lots of things to discuss, my favorite of which was the theme revolving around fate:  how the smallest of decisions & random occurrences can result in a catastrophic outcome.  There are many instances in Before the Fall where you will find that the smallest of choices mean the difference between life or death.  If just one small thing had been changed, would things have turned out differently?  Does everything happen for a reason?

Life is a series of decisions and reactions. It is the things you do and the things that are done to you.
And then it’s over.

Another aspect about this novel that I enjoyed was the portrayal of the “media frenzy” & how the media can spin facts to sensationalize a story.  It also touches upon some of the ethics of journalism & what lengths some are willing to go to get the story.  I actually wish this had been a bigger part of the novel as it was truly fascinating look at how the media can control which facts in a case are highlighted, thus swaying the audience one way or another.

I’m sure some people may have been disappointed with the ending, but I actually liked how everything panned out.  All of my theories from early on were way off, so kudos to Hawley for keeping me on my toes.  Towards the end of the book, I did begin to suspect the direction the book was going to go, but the big reveal was still the best part of this novel.  I was filled with tension and dread while reading scene where we finally figured out exactly what caused the plane crash.  The scariest part about this is that I could totally see this happening in real life, which is terrifying to think about.  It was all very believable.

 One of the downsides of this book, at least for me, was the pacing was not always consistent.  I found portions of some of the characters’ backstories to be a little monotonous & irrelevant.  That being said, I was wrapped up in the mystery enough to keep trudging on through the uninteresting parts to get to the more pertinent parts.  Just keep in mind this is a slow burning mystery, and not a fast paced novel.  

The way this book is laid out & some of the themes included reminded me a bit of the TV show Lost (but less weird), so if you enjoyed that show, I would recommend this book to you.  Rumor has it that the film rights were sold, and I would be very interested in seeing this book adapted to film.  I do think it would translate well to film, which isn’t a big shock as the author is a screen writer… I’m fairly sure he wrote this book with the film rights in the back of his mind.

Warning: Do not read this book on a plane 🙂



5-Star Rating System

3.5 Stars

*Big thanks to Grand Central Publishing for providing me with a copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.


About the Author

NoahHawley.pngNoah Hawley is an Emmy, Golden Globe, PEN, Critics’ Choice, and Peabody Award-winning author, screenwriter, and producer. He has published four novels and penned the script for the feature film Lies and Alibis. He created, executive produced, and served as showrunner for ABC’s My Generation and The Unusuals and was a writer and producer on the hit series Bones. Hawley is currently executive producer, writer, and showrunner on FX’s award-winning series, Fargo.

15 thoughts on “Book Review: Before the Fall by Noah Hawley”

  1. I think it’s being made into a film! I did like the idea too and I think the book was realistic, I just was expecting something completely different. If I had known that it was not a thriller, I would’ve enjoyed this more

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Insightful review Amanda! I remember talking about reading this one a few months back wayyyyy back lol. i still have it unread but mostly that’s because I ended up reading the many mixed reviews *le sigh* I still would like to give it a go though, seems like an interesting way of telling the story starting with the crash & alt. to present time. As always your reviews lend light & help me decide to read or not to read 😉


  3. Great review! I agree with you that it isn’t really a thriller. I went into it thinking it’d be nonstop action and drama, and it definitely was that slow-burn character study! I also read this for my book club, and we were pretty evenly split on whether or not we liked it. I didn’t like the book, though I did love those last couple pages, but those who liked it, really really liked it! I think the movie adaptation will be better than the book, as long as it is cast well.
    🙂 Great review!


  4. I think the #1 thing that handicapped this book was the assumption everyone seemed to have that it was a thriller. One woman at my book club tried to nominate this novel, but I didn’t vote for it. It just doesn’t sound like the kind of plot I’m interested in. Granted, I’m assuming most rich people are bad people and thus don’t care that the plane went down. Isn’t that awful? Don’t worry about trying to sway your book club’s choices of what to read; I do it all the time, too, lol. I try to at least make sure we read a book written by a woman so I can get a review for GTL out of it.


  5. That warning! XD It slays me. Good to know. I’ll keep that in mind.

    Every review I’ve seen has indicated that this isn’t a thriller. I think this is one of those weird situations where Goodreads metadata tags messed up some things in translation. However, this is the first review I’ve read where I was also persuaded to read the book. I love stories where the timeline jumps around, and I adore character development. So it looks like I’m picking this one up!

    Nothing like getting two birds with one stone for a book club selection, too. I always do a little happy dance when that happens.


  6. This review is so wonderfully written, I thoroughly enjoyed reading it! 🙂
    Before the Fall has been under my radar for quite some time, but I’ve been a little skeptical about adding it to my already brimming TBR pile, mainly because of the pace.
    – Definitely a book to keep in mind though, sounds like a pleasant read nonetheless.
    I look forward to more posts from you in the future… Happy Reading! 🙂


    1. Thank you so much for reading! Before the Fall is definitely a worth while read, HOWEVER I wouldn’t go out of your way to push it to the top of TBR… I think many people were expecting a heart pounding thriller from this book, but it just isn’t. Some parts felt a little thriller-ish but overall it is more of a character study. I hope you enjoy if you ever get the chance to pick it up 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.