Book Reviews, Historical Fiction

Book Review: The Tea Planter’s Wife by Dinah Jefferies

TheTeaPlantersWifeCover.jpg

As many of you know I am a big fan of historical fiction.  I am always on the lookout for historical fiction that is set in a place and/or time that I don’t know much about.  When I saw that The Tea Planter’s Wife is set in Ceylon in the 1920s, I knew I had to give it a go.

Divider2

TheTeaPlantersWifeAuthor:  Dinah Jefferies

Genre: Historical Fiction

Version: eBook

Publisher: Crown Publishing

Source: NetGalley

add-to-goodreads-button

amazon button

Book Description
#1 International bestselling novel set in 1920s Ceylon, about a young Englishwoman who marries a charming tea plantation owner and widower, only to discover he’s keeping terrible secrets about his past, including what happened to his first wife, that lead to devastating consequences
Nineteen-year-old Gwendolyn Hooper is newly married to a rich and charming widower, eager to join him on his tea plantation, determined to be the perfect wife and mother. But life in Ceylon is not what Gwen expected.
The plantation workers are resentful, the neighbours treacherous, and there are clues to the past – a dusty trunk of dresses, an overgrown gravestone in the grounds – that her husband refuses to discuss.
Just as Gwen finds her feet, disaster strikes. She faces a terrible choice, hiding the truth from almost everyone, but a secret this big can’t stay buried forever…. 


Divider2

MyThoughts

Set in Ceylon (under British colonial rule at the time – now Sri Lanka) in the 1920s, The Tea Planter’s Wife is a story of dark family secrets.  The story opens with our main character, Gwen, arriving to Ceylon to join her new husband & start their new life on the tea plantation he runs.

The overall story concept behind The Tea Planter’s Wife was a good idea and COULD have worked, but unfortunately didn’t due to the execution.  In my opinion, good historical fiction paints a picture of the era.  The setting is crucial because it sets the tone for the story.  If you are setting a story in Ceylon under British colonial rule in the 1920s, I want historical context so I feel like the story is in fact happening during that time & place.  There was so much potential here to enhance the story by exploring topics like  the tea making process, Ceylon’s culture, the racial tensions of the era between the British & the natives, etc.  Unfortunately, Jeffries merely touches upon these topics, instead of exploring them further and interweaving them throughout the plot.

Let’s talk about the characters.  NONE of the characters were likeable, not even the main character Gwen.  Gwen was a very naïve character, and I found myself shaking my head at her decisions frequently.  She also let people walk all over her throughout the entirety of the book, which is a fairly big pet peeve of mine.  Typically with these types of characters we see a tremendous amount of personal development & growth by the end of the book, but unfortunately Gwen ended up being a static character.  Laurence, her new husband, was a head scratcher too.  He was so closed off for the majority of the book, distancing himself from his new wife for no apparent reason.  At the end of the book he does give a lame excuse for being a royal ass to Gwen, but it was more of an afterthought.  There was zero chemistry between the newlyweds, Gwen and Laurence, so the romance aspect of the book was far from believable.   I also found the secondary characters more interesting than the primary characters, but alas there was not much development in those supporting roles.  I would have liked more development in Savi, Fran, Naveena, or even Verity.  At least these characters were interesting and not dull like Gwen & Laurence.  All around the board the characters were very flat and lacked the complexity that gives them a realistic feeling.

Elements of the plot were just odd that gave the story a disordered feeling.  This started off in the beginning with the prologue.  I kept waiting to see where the story was going to come full circle, but it didn’t.  It was really odd way to start off the book & didn’t really fit.  There were lots of holes throughout the plot.  Fran’s character pops in, but disappears.  Gwen mentions her parents & her desires to see them, yet they never come.  Also, there was a odd sex scene between Gwen & Laurence where he “lost control” and was too rough?  Laurence basically rapes Gwen, but it’s never really mentioned afterwards? He just apologizes for being too rough?  I wont even go into Laurence’s reveal at the end of the book.  The plot was far too messy, making for a muddled reading experience.

Overall, this book was just not my cup of tea.  Pun intended 🙂

Divider2


MyRating

5-Star Rating System

*Big thanks to Crown Publishing for providing me with a copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Divider2

About the Author

DinahJefferiesI was born in Malaysia  and moved to England at the age of nine.
As a teenager I missed the heat of Malaysia, which left me with a kind of restlessness that led to quite an unusual life. I went to live in Tuscany where I worked as an au-pair for an Italian countess, and there was even a time when I lived with a rock band in a ‘hippie’ commune in Suffolk.
In 1985, the death of my fourteen year old son changed everything. Although it was the darkest of times and I will always miss him, I’m grateful for the years we had together, and I now draw on the experience of loss in my writing. I set my books abroad and aim to infuse the love and loss with the extremely seductive beauty of the East.
My second novel, The Tea Planter’s Wife, was a Richard & Judy Book Club Autumn in 2015 pick as well as being  number one in the Sunday Times Bestselling list. It also reached number 1 in the Italian eBook charts for that year. And those are somethings I’m absolutely delighted about. Book three, The Silk Merchant’s Daughter, was published in February 2016 and also entered Sunday Times Bestselling list as well as the best seller lists in Italy . Book four which is set in 1930s India, Before the Rains, was published in the UK February 2017 and this too entered the best seller lists for both hard copy and eBook in Italy. All my novels are published in the UK/Commonwealth by Penguin/Viking. My books have now been published in over 25 different countries across the globe and this number is still increasing.
Although my husband and I spent five wonderful years living  in a small 16th Century village in Northern Andalusia, I’m happy to say we now live close to our family in Gloucestershire .

Website • FacebookTwitter

Divider2
LetsChat

Have you read The Tea Planter’s Wife?  If so, what did you think?

13 thoughts on “Book Review: The Tea Planter’s Wife by Dinah Jefferies”

  1. Sigh. I’m so sorry this didn’t work out for you. It disappoints me. I’ve been finding that I am now shying away from historical fiction, once a favorite genre of mine, because of exactly what you mention above: The history needs to be a character. The setting needs to be integral to the plot. Without it, we’re just reading contemporary fiction with old-fashioned sensibilities. It’s like playing dress-up.

    I’m sorry this disappointed you. Why do you think this book might have become a best seller despite your personal opinions?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. “The history needs to be a character. The setting needs to be integral to the plot. Without it, we’re just reading contemporary fiction with old-fashioned sensibilities. It’s like playing dress-up.”

      Yes Jackie! You nailed it on the head. I guess I hold historical fiction to a higher standard. It feels like many authors are attempting this genre, but are not doing the leg work & research that is standard for a good historical fiction.

      I have no idea how this book became a best seller. I think the concept of this book probably grabbed a bunch of HF fan’s attentions, like it did my own. It has a 3.75 star rating, so maybe it just didn’t work for me personally.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. It’s okay if you don’t enjoy a book other people enjoy! In fact, I find this makes for a stronger book club. If everyone enjoys the book there is little discussion to be had. … … Oooh, that is good inspiration for another BBBC! Mwahaha. Thank you, Amanda! 😉

        I find that often disappointing books become best sellers because the marketing leads to a ton of early sales. Kudos to the publishers, authors, and agents who make this happen! But it does often lead more critical readers like ourselves astray. Hopefully your next historical fiction is wonderful!

        Like

  2. Excellent review! I actually got a physical copy of this when Blogging for Books was still around (how I miss them!), and tried several times to read and get into this one. I finally pushed through it but just didn’t like it. I agree that no one was really likable, and out of everything going on within the plot, I just couldn’t force myself to care.

    Like

Leave a Reply to Yvo Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.